3 Clear Indicators You May Have Retired Prematurely and Effective Solutions You Can Implement Right Away

Is Early Retirement Right for You?

fizkes / Getty Images

Retiring ahead of schedule can be rewarding, but it often demands more careful preparation than many anticipate. If you find yourself rapidly depleting your savings, struggling with healthcare expenses, or feeling a lack of direction, it may be time to reconsider your approach.

Highlights

• Excessive spending, escalating medical costs, and a lack of daily structure could indicate you left the workforce prematurely.
• Retiring early may result in a permanent reduction of your Social Security benefits, which can further diminish your retirement funds.
• If you suspect you retired too soon, options like downsizing, seeking new income sources, or returning to work can help restore your financial stability.

More than half of Americans retire earlier than they originally planned, often due to unforeseen circumstances such as health problems or layoffs, according to the Transamerica Center for Retirement Studies. Even those who choose to retire early can face unexpected financial and emotional hurdles.

Whether you’re already retired or nearing that stage, recognizing the warning signs of retiring too soon can help you make timely adjustments and protect your financial future.

Sign #1: Your Spending Is Outpacing Expectations

Many retirees find themselves overspending in the initial years, especially if they’re in good health and eager to enjoy new experiences. However, this can quickly erode your savings.

Mallon FitzPatrick, head of wealth planning at Robertson Stephens, notes that younger retirees often underestimate their expenses, particularly when travel and leisure activities become more frequent. Without a steady income, even minor splurges can disrupt your long-term financial plans. If you notice your withdrawals increasing or your savings dwindling faster than anticipated, it’s wise to review your budget. Tracking your spending for several months can highlight problem areas, and setting realistic allowances for hobbies and travel can help you stay on course. Make it a habit to revisit your budget at least annually, or more often if your lifestyle changes.

If minor adjustments aren’t enough, consider bigger changes. Downsizing your home can free up cash and strengthen your financial position. Some retirees generate extra income by renting out a second property or an accessory dwelling unit on their main residence.

Alternatively, you might explore starting a side business or taking on part-time work. FitzPatrick suggests keeping an open mind—perhaps there’s a new skill you’d like to learn or a different type of job you’d enjoy.

Sign #2: Healthcare Expenses Are Draining Your Savings

Leaving the workforce before age 65 means you won’t have access to Medicare, and securing affordable health insurance on your own can be challenging. FitzPatrick warns that rising premiums and healthcare costs can quickly eat into your retirement savings.

Combined with inflation and market fluctuations, these expenses can pose a significant threat to early retirees. Claiming Social Security benefits early can also result in permanently reduced monthly payments, whereas waiting can lead to much higher lifetime benefits.

To safeguard your finances, explore all available health coverage options. Check if you qualify for subsidies through the Health Insurance Marketplace to help lower your premiums. Joining a spouse’s employer-sponsored plan may also be a cost-effective solution.

If you’re leaving a job, COBRA coverage allows you to extend your previous employer’s health plan for up to 18 months, though it often comes at a higher price. Some part-time positions offer health benefits, which can help you avoid dipping into your savings for medical costs.

Sign #3: You Miss the Structure and Security of Work

The reality of retirement doesn’t always match the dream. Many retirees struggle with a loss of routine or sense of purpose.

FitzPatrick points out that feeling aimless or lacking motivation is a common but often overlooked sign of retiring too soon. If you’re feeling this way, consider picking up new hobbies, volunteering, or even working part-time to regain a sense of fulfillment.

Returning to full-time work is another option to consider. Some early retirees discover that rejoining the workforce provides social interaction and intellectual engagement they miss. Even a few additional years of employment can significantly improve your long-term financial outlook. FitzPatrick recalls advising a client who wanted to retire at 50 but wasn’t financially prepared; instead, she took a short sabbatical and later transitioned to a less demanding job, maintaining her lifestyle without drastic cutbacks.

Final Thoughts

Retiring early isn’t necessarily a misstep, but it does require thoughtful planning. If you’re burning through your savings, facing high healthcare costs, or feeling lost, it may be time to make changes. This could involve downsizing, renting out property, starting a side business, or returning to work in some capacity—even full-time if needed.

With the right adjustments, you can strengthen both your financial security and your sense of purpose in retirement—no matter when you start.